DUTHIL: PAST AND PRESENT.
|
Part III
[50] The first Free Church minister of Duthil who left the impress of ministerial usefulness on the community was the Rev. John Logan, who was translated from Dundee. He was a fearless man, bold and impulsive, but warm-hearted, vigorous, and weighty as a preacher, and capable as an organiser. His memory is still fresh, and is held in veneration by the generation who passed through his Bible class, many of whom are still living. He was not long, however, in the parish when he came into collision with the "men".
The most conspicuous of the "men" of Duthil were William Grant of Slochd (meaning "pit", the worst place in time and eternity, he used to say), familiar to travellers by the Highland Railway, and John Mackintosh, a meek and humble Christian, and a good religious poet. See Oranan Nuadh Spioradail, le Ian Macintoisich, a Bha 'n Tor an Spardain, Strathspei. Inbhirnis, 1844.The first edition of his poems (1844) contains "In Praise of the Saviour," a long piece of [51] twenty-seven verses of eight lines each; "Sad News," in which the writer, true to the Celtic character, glories in the past and mourns the departure of eminent ministers, such as Mr Porteous, Mr Gunn (Golspie), Mr Hector M'Phail, Mr Calder of Croy(?), Mr Hugh Mackay of Moy, and Mr Alex. Fraser of Kirk-hill; "The Misery of the Lovers of the World" is an earnest warning; against rejecting the Gospel; "A Lament" on Rev. Mr Robertson, Kingussie, shows how highly esteemed was that evangelical preacher, whose preaching attracted God-fearing people from all the surrounding parishes; the last is an elegy on Thomas Macdonald of Strathdearn (Moy). His grip of sound theology can be seen from the following verse :—
"Us theirear mac an duine ris
Ge iongantach leibh e ;
'Us theirear Uan an Athair ris,
'S cha lagh an iognadh e ;
Uan bhi anns an diadhaidheachd
'Us Dia bhi mar ri daoine
Tha e gu leir na dhiamhaireachd
'Us co don aithne el"
The others of this group of men were James Macgregor, Robert Macpherson,
and Duncan [52] Cameron, the
Boanerges of the party. Duncan Cameron was the son of
Pipe-Major Cameron, a native of Duthil, who, for chivalrous devotion to his
superior officer in the Canadian War, received recognition. This Pipe-Major
married Ann Fraser from Kirkhill. Duncan was born in the garrison of Fort-William
in 1798. He was very reticent about his conversion, but this is substantially
how he related it to his bosom friends.
As a young man Duncan's company was much sought at convivial gatherings, he
being of an exceptionally happy disposition, wTith an ardent love for music.
He played the bagpipes and the fiddle. On a certain occasion at a certain
place where a number of people were gathered, there was much mirth and hilarity.
There was dancing and music and good cheer. The company dispersed about midnight,
and on retiring to rest some time after midnight, when all was dark and still,
and all were hushed in sleep, the room in which Duncan slept became suddenly
filled with light. The brightness awoke Duncan at this strange hour of the
night, and if the unwonted light was strange and calculated to make one tremble,
the apparition at the window was very much more so, for there stood in bodily
shape the Prince of Darkness, who can be transformed into an Angel of Light.
From this point Duncan became a changed man. He was still but a youth, but
the life he lived abundantly manifested that a great and radical change had
taken place. On the morning after this strange sight he destroyed what he
so much loved, and what made his company to be in continual request in convivial
gatherings—his bagpipes and his fiddle.Duncan was a strong, well-built
man, with a striking individuality. Possessed of a fertile intellect, and
untrammelled by the motion of time or the tendency of ordinary mortals to
sleep in a close atmosphere, he would discourse till cock-crow, and sometimes
long after, on his favourite theme — the life of Joseph, spiritualising
incidents in the life, and applying the lessons with effect. Almost a Covenanter
by conviction, he was entirely one in sentiment.
[53] Clad in his big blue cloak,
he was an interesting figure on Communion occasions at Creich and Dingwall
in the days of Dr Aird and Dr Kennedy. When a young man Duncan was catechised
by Joseph Mackay, on whom, in later life, he wrote an elegy. The questions
put and answers given give us an interesting glimpse of those early catechisings,
as well as of the persons specially before us. Joseph asked him the question,
" What is prayer ?" and he answered it correctly. He was then asked,
" Are you a praying person ?" "I am," he replied firmly.
" And do you pray for others as well as yourself?" "I do,"
replied Duncan. " Could you testify to me that you do." " Yes
; when others are asleep I am often out praying that they may be well, and
that their crops may get on as well as my own." "Now," said
Joseph, "I saw that I had no ordinary material to deal with, and I next
asked him, " Do you love the Lord's people ?" " I do,"
he answered boldly. " And wrould you be willing to give part of anything
you had to them ? " " Yes, I would be willing." " And
if you expected any of them to the house, would you be willing to go as far
as Grantown for anything they might need?" "Yes, I would go as far
as Inverness for anything they might [54]
require." "If you had something in the house keeping for one of
your own special favourites, and if one of His people came the way that you
did not esteem so highly, would you give it to that person freely?" "At
last," said Joseph, " Duncan sat down, saying, ' If you had left
that, I would have made a man' " (meaning one of the " men").
Towards the end of a long and stirring life he met one of his opponents, to
whom he offered his hand, saying, " James, I am going to eternity, and
I do not wish to go with anything between any creature and myself." His
last appearance in public, on the Friday of the Communion at Duthil, revealed
the mellowed Christian. He burst into prayer, pleading that all who wronged
him might be forgiven, and asking forgiveness for every wrong he had done
to anyone. He closed his eyes in the long sleep listening to the fifth chapter
of Revelation being read, and the first verse of the sixth Psalm being sung,
at his own request.See Free Presbyterian Magazine. Vol.
I. pp. 464-5, and Vol. II. p. 62.
There was another group of " men" contemporaries of the former, devout and loyal men, without a taint of separatism in their nature, whose affectionate attachment to their [55] minister was a helpful contribution to the moral and spiritual power of the pulpit in the parish. They were Duncan Cameron, Alexander Cumming, Robert Gumming, Lachlan MacKintosh, Peter Cumming, and Sandy Watson. Of the former group William Grant was the acknowledged leader, though facts indicate that he wras forced into a position which he did not wholly enjoy. William lived, as already noted, on the eerie slope of Slochd-muic, where the winter winds blew cold and strong, as the gnarled and twisted birches struggling for existence in that awful gorge clearly show. Hemarkable for piety rather than eloquence or even freedom of expression, his religious experiences were of the deeply subjective type. In surroundings naturally adapted to the contemplation of the mysterious, he cultivated the mystic element in his nature in long and contemplative communion with God. Like a seer of the desert, he came forth from his retirement with wonderful visions, striking interpretations of God's work in providence and grace, and spiritual solutions for many of the problems that press down the genuinely religious. But he was not without his limitations and defects any more than other mystics who hover on the borderland between [56] the visible and invisible and what is revealed and what is withheld. Here his vivid imagination grasped at its own fancy as if it were a clear and direct vision from God.
In his house and elsewhere regular meetings were held, where the reading of a sermon, translated impromptu, and the usual devotional exercises constituted the strictly religious part.
The rest of the meeting took the form of what might be termed, in the parlance
of the present-day Church folk, a " social evening." By unfriendly
critics this has been given the older name of " love feasts," with
a stinging suggestion as to their doubtful moral tone and effect. Those who
frequented these meetings, and some of them are still living, give an emphatic
testimony against such a suggestion. As a matter of fact, they were regulated
by religious principles, and were in imitation of the practice of early Christians.
Most of the time w^as occupied in chanting Gaelic sacred songs, with intervals
for exchange of opinion on points of doctrine or questions of experimental
religion. The poems that found most favour with them were those of Dugald
Buchanan, See Spiritual Hymns, by Dugald Buchanan, any
Edition. [57] the greatest
of all Gaelic religious bards, as well as those of Mrs Clarke of Badenoch,
a poetess of great merit, See Gaelic Hymns, by Mrs Clarke,
any Edition and those of other popular but minor poets. This practice
was not peculiar to this parish only. Indeed, throughout the whole Highlands
the sacred songs of the people's poets were freely sung, and this was a strong
factor in disseminating the Reformed Faith, and in counteracting the evil
influences of the immoral realism of the more sordid and coarse of the secular
bards. Further, this gave an impetus to verse making, to which William Grant
and Duncan Cameron applied their heads and hearts ; but it would be unjust
to the men themselves, as well as discreditable to the beauty of Gaelic anthology,
to describe their efforts as poetry. Two elegies, one on " Ann Grant,
Broom Park," and another on " Miss Grant Aitean liath," Both
these women were eminent in their day for piety. are ascribed to William.
Along with these are a dirge on " The troubles of the Time," with
some sarcastic references to the Disruption enthusiasm, and a mournful meditation
on the " Fears of the People of the World in the World," and "A
Song on.Woman" (married), which contains much shrewd advice. All these
men [58] were diligent students
of the Bible. They were familiar with Puritan theology 5 the writings of the
Scottish Divines, and the History of the Reformation, and were all ardent
Protestants. The privileges and the responsibilities of the great house of
Argyll, William quaintly summarised in the words, " The house of Argyll
is in debt to heaven for the Truth." It is gratifying to record that
on his deathbed he deplored his opposition to and estrangement from Rev. Mr
Cook, and expressed his unfeigned respect for the Rev. Mr Logan.
In William's declining years he is said to have had a vision, the reality
and significance of which he did not doubt. On this vision hangs a tale, which
may be interesting or amusing, according to the mental viewpoint from which
it is to be considered. Unfortunately, it was not awant-ing in those elements
which, when disturbed, can still awaken feelings of resentment. There was
a persistent tradition in the parish of a Morayshire lady who was reared in
affluence, but died in penury. She married a man of the people in the Coigs
of Strathdearn — made famous later as the birthplace of the renowned
[59] Dr Angus Mackintosh of
Tain. Here she lived for a time, and was held in great respect as an eminently
pious woman. Having migrated to Abernethy, on her death-bed there she gave
strict orders that her remains should be laid to rest alongside the dust of
her husband's forbears in the ancient churchyard at Dalarossie. On being told
of the difficulty of crossing the dangerous and treacherous Spey, she still
insisted on her request, assuring those around her that a passage would be
opened up for them when they reached the water. Here the traditions differ.
According to one, when the funeral party reached the river, and the coffin
was brought to its brink, the waters suddenly divided, and a passage through
the dry bed of the river was effected. The other is that the ferry boat, which
was on the opposite side, slipped its moorings without any human intervention,
and sailed across to the waiting party, who deposited the coffin in it, and
thus got the remains across. The former of the two traditions, however, was
almost universally accepted as the true one. But the actual place of crossing
was known only to a few, to whom the knowledge was transmitted in oral tradition.
It was the revelation of this obscurity to William Grant, who had never [60]
seen the spot, and yet described it with a minuteness of detail which included
even the size and shape of the bush which marked the spot, that strengthened
his own belief and that of his followers in the authenticity of the tradition,
as well as the reality of the vision. He accordingly gave instructions that
a certain slate slab (also pointed out to him in the vision) in Slochd should
be hewn out without the aid of hammer or chisel (for the sound of no iron
or wood instrument was to be heard thereon), and set up as a memorial stone
to mark to all generations this miraculous crossing of the Spey. These visions
seem to such as have not sufficient regard for the truth that " the secret
of the Lord is with them that fear Him," as spiritual phenomena which,
by a cold analysis, can be proved to be an exaggerated product of the violent
activities of the contemplative spirit. The glowing visions of modern prophets
in the Church and State could also, doubtless, be traced by the acute critic
to prepossessions which the creative energy of a fertile intellect and imagination
casts in such an alluring and attractive form as gives them the appearance
of reality. The schools of the latter prophets denounce the-followers of the
former as superstitious fanatics.
[61] The fundamental principles
which differentiate these schools, when considered, may help to give those
" visions" their true perspective, and accordingly the amount of
credence of which they are deserving. Men like William Grant held as their
basic principle a profound and unshakable belief in the being and attributes
of God, His sovereignty in the world, and His illimitable power in the spiritual
and physical realms. Within the sphere of His -activities there was room for
infinite possibilities consistent with His own glory. The Scriptures were
accepted as infallible and inerrant. Whereas the others confine the activities
of God within the narrow region circumscribed by pure reason, where activities
are gauged •according to their ethical importance ; or, denying the
existence of God altogether, they look upon the world as the product of evolutionary
forces, moving upwards towards the ideal of the visions.
There were people in Duthil who believed in William's vision as well as his
piety, and after his death they took steps to give effect to his wish. Forgetful,
however, of his last request, they applied both hammer and chisel to the prescribed
stone, first in cutting it out of its [62]
native bed, and then in inscribing on it an elaborate history of the person
and event it was intended to commemorate. When all things were ready, the
stone was laid on a cart, and a solemn procession was formed, which wended
its way to the famous spot, where it was erected with befitting ceremony.
On the following Sabbath a larger crowd came to see the stone than went to
hear the minister. The Rev. Mr Logan unsparingly denounced those Sabbath breakers.
Youthful and ardent spirits in the congregation inferred that the minister
would not regard with disfavour the removal of the cause of the Sabbath breaking.
So it happened that, in the stillness of night, in the following week, some
unknown persons smashed the stone and threw the fragments into the Spey on
the north side of the river, not far from Boat of Garten Station, where interested
persons may still see them. A conflict of bitter feeling arose between the
party of " sacrilege " and the party of " superstition,"
which might have been avoided by the display of some humour and a real respect
for the religious aspect of the affair, as well as some mutual forbearance.
It is perhaps a pity that the stone was not allowed to remain, as it
[63] would form a subject of study to the antiquarians of
the " Field Club " at Inverness of greater interest than the discovery
of a St Andrew's cross at Morile, Tomatin, which threw one of their notables
into ecstasies, and the local people into merriment, as the discovered cross
was nothing more poetic than incisions on a boulder for the iron frame of
a threshing mill.
One painful effect of this clashing of party spirit was visible in absenteeism from church ordinances on the part of some of the "men" and a few of their followers. Incidents which gave spiritual distress to Mr Logan were accompanied by explosions of temper, which were a source of personal danger to him. Still he continued labouring successfully among the-people, pointedly rebuking all forms of sin, and instilling into the youthful minds higher views of life and morality. He harboured no ill-feeling to those who gave him most annoyance.. A busybody of a familiar type came to the manse to comfort him in the midst of his. troubles with that form of sympathy which, to a sensitive, religious soul, is more stinging than consoling, and spoke with dubiety about the religious qualities of some of the men.
[64] "Duncan," he replied, " will be on the right hand at the great day, but you may be on the left."
Mr Logan accepted a call to Macdonald Church, Glasgow, much to the distress
of his attached people. He died minister of that congregation. He is buried
at Lawers.
[72] When this policy of the Church culminated in the Union of 1900, a very small stream trickled off from the right, also on a new course. Like a burn rushing violently down a steep Highland mountain, whose sound is deceptive when heard from afar, as its rush is much in excess of that of the river, so the noise it creates is out of proportion to its size. But let it be placed to the credit of the residenters, whose eyes, resting on the massive shoulders of the Cairngorm and the mighty waters of the Spey, can appreciate proportions, and can distinguish between a mountain and an ant-heap, and between a river and a hill-stream, that they have left to passing vocalists to noise abroad the size and importance of their congregation. The few local people of which this congregation consists, with two or three exceptions, cannot trace their pedigree far into the past of Duthil, so that they neither reflect nor represent the thought or religious life of any body in particular. The river flows notwithstanding all that has transpired, in the same old bed, noiselessly and effectively as before, fertilising the moral and spiritual life of the surrounding area. This is not by any means to be read as an essential disparagement of the Established [73] or the United Free Churches. It is but a statement of facts collected and observed.
The Rev. James Bain, of the Established Church, whose ministry now extends over a long period, entered into possession of an heritage that was in disfavour. Thereafter, although he has been an able and ardent evangelical preacher, a conservative theologian, and an opponent of all innovations in the matter or mode of worship, his congregation has not appreciably increased under his ministry. In the district churches a number of Free Church people have been in attendance since 1900, owing;, on the one hand, to the lazy habit of remaining away from the central church fostered by the accommodating policy referred to, and, on the other hand, to the inability of the Free Church to supply ordinances in these districts.
Here there is a striking illustration of the divisions of Presbyterianism. It is divided into four parts, and where Presbyterianism before the Disruption was served by one church, and for a long time after by two, it has now, with a declining population, six churches, three halls or meeting houses, and the use of a school room. On these gaunt and featureless edifices the sublime beauty of nature round about looks with [74] derision and scorn. They stare the passer-by in stark unmitigated condemnation of the policy that reared most of them. Although the noble and heroic efforts for conscience sake of the sectaries of Scotland form the most thrilling pages of our national history, the policy that divided the Free Church into three unequal parts was neither noble nor heroic, nor does it appear to have operated in obedience to the imperious command of conscience shone upon by the Light, as its results, the best test of a religious movement, sadly show. It has failed to advance the kingdom of God, at least in this parish.
Perhaps the most eminent of recent visitors is the renowned Baptist minister,
Dr Alexander Maclaren of Manchester. Without a compeer among living English-speaking
preachers, an illuminating Bible expositor, a master of a
[78] pellucid but glowing and vivacious style, many of his
sermons are a string of lustrous gems, carefully arranged in artistic and
exquisite setting. Few of the multitude in the Anglo-Saxon world, who are
constantly his debtors, know that volumes of his monumental work, " Expositions
of the Holy Scriptures," now nearirig completion, were prepared for publication
during his four months' residence in " Crai-gowan," which nestles
cosily on the lower ledge of a pine-clad slope near Oarr-Bridge, in remote
Duthil. Pious people there are still in Duthil, who, it may be from their
inability to appreciate the beautiful, sympathise with the Caithness worthy,
whose friendly criticism of an ornate sermon was that " gems were verra
bonnie, but ye canna eat them." Those who still read sermons satisfy
their spiritual hunger rather on the repast provided in the weekly sermons
of even a greater Baptist preacher—Charles H. Spurgeon. Nevertheless
the people are proud of their famous visitor, and would gladly hear him oftener
than it has been their privilege. He rarely preaches among them. On one particular
occasion, he did promise to preach, but the promise was a bitter disappointment
to an eager and expectant congregation, for another had to be secured in
[79] his place, and no reason
for his absence was forthcoming. Early on Monday morning, one of the residenters
in the parish, in feverish anxiety about the Doctor's health, made haste to
enquire, but to his joyful surprise, who met him on the bridge but Dr Maclaren,
meditatively gazing into the boiling waters of the noisy Dulnan and smoking
hard at his pipe in evident enjoyment of good health and a good smoke. He
went no further with his enquiry, and no reason was given for disappointing
the people on the previous day. A certain natural reserve and shy aloofness
stand between him and the frank exchange of sentiments with the common people,
so characteristic of Dr Calder-wood. Two occasions which were intended to
be memorable and historic, and in which he was the central figure, require
to be mentioned in pages dealing with the history of the parish. The first
was at the laying of the foundation stone of the new United Free Church at
Carr-Bridge, and the second was at the opening of that Church. As he stood
at the foundation ceremony, he presented a striking figure. Here was the world-renowned
preacher, with rounded shoulders bearing the burden of four score years and
more, leaning heavily on his staff. Wisps of grey hair floated in the gentle
[80] breeze. Underneath the
chin and jaw bones was a thin belt of grey beard. The face was puckered, the
mouth sunken, and the fleshless lips stretched tightly. The sparkling and
alert eye below a high and imposing forehead betrayed the intellectual force
of this imposing personality. There was nothing really about the face that
arrested attention but these, unless it may be that the lower part indicated
determination, not entirely aloof from a certain form of meanness. The words
flowed readily and aptly from his lips. The accent was more reminiscent of
Perthshire than Manchester, and the homeliness of the rough grey tweed suit
reminded one of the " men" rather than a Doctor of Divinity. The
speech was an eulogy on the great and learned ministers of the United Free
Church. The praise of that denomination was unstinted. At the opening ceremony
his address took the form of an expression of deep sympathy for the U.F. people
in their trials, and a whole-hearted and earnest appeal to his audience to
give heed, regardless even of creeds and confessions, to Christ's message—"Abide
in Me." It was befitting the occasion that sympathy should be extended
to the denomination represented by the building, hut it would have been equally
befitting not to [81] ignore
the existence of the Established Church as an intellectual and moral force.
Indeed, if the biographer is correct who writes thus of him—" Dr
Maclaren has never been consumed by that passion which seeks to sink distinctive
principles in favour of a Church the price of whose comprehensiveness would
be a vague, colourless, indeterminate creed" See
British Monthly, September, 1905. —it would not have unduly strained
Christian charity to have given a passing nod of sympathy to the poor people
around him in Duthil who, for the very reason for which he does not join the
other Evangelical Free Churches in England, still hold by the distinctive
principles of their own Church. Their trials were severer than those which
evoked his warm sympathy. For, did they not worship in pelting rain, on the
sodden earth beneath the birches through which the cold wind was sighing ?
Did they not also worship where horses neighed and pranced, and yet no word
of sympathy was heard, no kindly look of pity was seen ? They were, however,
they said, sustained by the comforting belief that the Great Master of Assemblies
did, in the days of His flesh, visit and bless His people in other places
than temples made with man's [82]
hands, and that even the stable itself is hallowed, inasmuch as it was it
alone of all this Divinity-visited world that extended its protection and
comfort to the Heavenly Visitor, when His infant frame was laid in the place
out of which horses eat their corn.
Other great men have been visiting Duthil, and in this way this comparatively
remote parish is known to the larger world beyond. It is yearly growing in
importance as a visitor's locality.
[83] What shall the future of this parish be ? This is a parish that was at one time the possession of the ferocious and warlike Comyns, and became, partly by conquest, and partly by marriage settlement, the property of the Grants. It gave birth to Gilbert Comyn (Gibban Mor), to a field-marshal (Sir Patrick Grant), and to men who bled in their country's cause in fields of battle over all the continents of the world. From it went forth men that have made their mark in all walks of life. In it are the remains of a past civilisation suited to the tastes of archaeologists. The field naturalists will find its three tiers of forests in Slochd-muic and stately relics of an ancient forest, as well as its rich flora, full of interest. It has its folklore and its secular as well as sacred poetry. Above all it is full of splendid traditions associated with the lives of truly pious men and women. It must have a future. With its educational facilities, its sons will surely hold their own with other sons of the Empire in life's strenuous struggle. If its straths are again to be peopled, may it not yet be that, as [84] m times gone by, the passer-by may point to its homes and say ?—
"In dwellings of the righteous
Is heard the melody
Of joy and health; the Lord's right hand
Doth ever valiantly."
This reviving of spiritual religion, this quickening to a holier life, and this return to a less materialistic and more truly pious living, judging from the past religious history of the parish, shall be accomplished under God, by the minister or ministers who shall act on Thomas Goodwin's advice to his students to thicken their too thin homilies with more doctrine.
![]() |
Part III |
![]() |
![]() |